CP
Catherine Pepinster
Social Issues & Demographics · United Kingdom
Covers
Social Issues & Demographics
Arts & Culture
Politics & Government
International Affairs
Breaking News & General Assignment
Health & Wellness
Seen in
Published work
The Independent
Jul 2026
Why Burnham is Britain’s first ‘full-fat Catholic’ prime minister
Burnham’s long-standing Catholic identity marks a historic first for a British prime minister, raising potential political and practical implications linked to Church–state roles, assisted dying legislation and faith‑school funding. His personal religious influences and past public signals of allegiance are highlighted alongside comparisons with various popes’ leadership styles, offering guidance on what to emulate or avoid as he assumes office.
The Independent
Mar 2026
Will an ex-nurse as the church’s first female Archbishop of Canterbury help its medicine go down?
Sarah Mullally’s enthronement as the first female Archbishop of Canterbury is presented as a historic but potentially contentious choice. Her experience as an NHS chief nurse and Bishop of London makes her a safe, capable administrator, but conservative Anglicans and some international churches oppose women bishops, while her support for prayers accompanying same-sex blessings may deepen divisions. She also inherits severe challenges, including declining church attendance, strained relations with other Christian denominations and the Church of England’s continuing safeguarding crisis. Her success will depend on restoring trust and offering stability after Justin Welby’s troubled departure.
The Independent
Feb 2026
At this brutal time for the monarchy, King Charles must convince us he cares
Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor’s arrest has exposed a crisis for the British monarchy, while King Charles and other royals continue their public engagements under a tradition of carrying on with duty. The article argues that the House of Windsor’s motto of “never complain, never explain” is no longer sufficient as public expectations have shifted toward visible emotional empathy. Historical examples including Aberfan and the death of Diana show the risks of royal detachment, while more recent personal disclosures by Charles and Catherine suggest the family has begun adapting. Charles may avoid commenting while the police investigation and legal process continue, but he could later face intense pressure to address the public directly; how he responds may affect both the legacy of his reign and the monarchy’s future.
The Independent
Jan 2026
The Only Person Who Can Stop Donald Trump Now Is Pope Leo
Pope Leo XIV is urged to take a stronger public stand against Donald Trump’s possible U.S. military intervention in Venezuela. Drawing on Leo’s experience in Peru and his familiarity with Venezuelan refugees, the piece argues that he is not aligned with Trump despite being American-born. It presents the pope’s global moral authority and the Holy See’s diplomatic network, including its influence at the United Nations, as powerful tools for opposing intervention and protecting Venezuelan sovereignty and civilians.
The Independent
Oct 2025
Charles has forged a holy bond with the Pope – but will William break it?
Charles III has developed a close relationship with the Pope and demonstrated a strong commitment to Christianity and Catholicism, including supporting the removal of historic restrictions on Catholics in a senior Church of Scotland role. The Vatican has honored him with a spiritual distinction. In contrast, William, Prince of Wales, is portrayed as having shown little engagement with religion beyond formal royal ceremonies. This raises questions about whether he will embrace the explicitly Christian nature of the coronation and whether the monarchy can retain a sense of profound spiritual purpose under his future reign.
The Independent
Oct 2025
Lord help us – the church is agonising over same-sex couples again
The Church of England is preparing another debate and vote on allowing standalone blessings for same-sex couples, while bishops have extended the ban on clergy marrying same-sex partners. The piece argues that legalistic bureaucracy, internal politics, financial pressure from evangelical donors and concern about conservative African members of the global Anglican Communion are preventing meaningful progress. Sarah Mullally’s appointment as the first woman Archbishop of Canterbury briefly united groups usually divided over the church’s future, but the renewed dispute has restored the institution’s underlying tensions.
The Independent
Sep 2025
What influencer Carlo Acutis becoming a saint says about Pope Leo’s Catholic Church
Carlo Acutis, the London-born Italian teenager known as “God’s influencer” for his faith, website design and love of technology, is being canonized by Pope Leo XIV. His popularity reflects his youth, kindness, tragic early death and modern digital image, including his livestreamed tomb in Assisi. The piece also highlights how canonization typically favors clergy and founders of religious orders because their supporters can finance extensive investigations, miracle claims and Vatican advocacy. Acutis’s mother funded his cause, prompting criticism of a system in which ordinary people may lack comparable access. The article argues that the Church should consider broader methods, such as public acclamation, to honor other selfless people whose lives remain largely unrecognized.
The Independent
Jun 2025
Does the Church of England actually need a new Archbishop of Canterbury?
The Church of England's local congregations have continued operating normally despite Justin Welby's resignation, with Archbishop of York Stephen Cottrell handling urgent institutional matters. However, the vacant Archbishop of Canterbury position creates problems for the established church, including the absence of a senior voice in the House of Lords, a gap in ceremonial precedence and altered relations with the monarchy. The Crown Nominations Commission's lengthy selection process reflects difficult debates over issues such as same-sex blessings and whether the next archbishop could be a woman. The commentary argues, humorously, for a faster conclave-style election.
The Independent
May 2025
Is Leo XIV the liberal Pope who’s going to take on Trump?
Pope Leo XIV, formerly Chicago-born Cardinal Robert Prevost, is presented as an American pontiff shaped by missionary and pastoral work in Peru and by concern for poverty and injustice. His papal name evokes Leo XIII’s advocacy of workers’ rights, while his apparent alignment with Pope Francis’s Latin American, pro-poor approach and a social-media repost criticizing Trump and JD Vance’s migration policies suggest potential tension with the Trump administration. His advisers also appear to envision him as a bridge-builder capable of healing divisions within the Church and wider world.
The Independent
May 2025
Know what the conclave needs? A woman’s touch…
The upcoming papal conclave exposes the Catholic Church’s deeply male-dominated hierarchy, but women already exert more influence than is often recognized through religious orders, schools, theology and senior Vatican appointments. The article praises Pope Francis for opening leadership roles to women and argues that nuns such as Raffaella Petrini, Simona Brambilla and Nathalie Becquart could shape the choice of pope. Drawing on Isabella Rossellini’s role in the film Conclave, it ultimately advocates allowing women a more direct role in the conclave, potentially including female cardinals.
The Independent
Apr 2025
Meet the British cardinals who will help choose the next Pope
England and Wales have an unprecedented four cardinals associated with the next papal conclave: Vincent Nichols, Arthur Roche, Michael Fitzgerald and Timothy Radcliffe. Nichols, Roche and Radcliffe are young enough to vote and could potentially be considered for the papacy, while Fitzgerald may still influence pre-conclave discussions despite being ineligible to vote. Their presence reflects improving Catholic–Anglican relations and gives Britain significant experience of both contemporary Catholicism and Vatican politics, although none is regarded as a leading papal favorite.
The Independent
Apr 2025
Pope Francis was the first pontiff to write a memoir, but some dark secrets were never revealed
Pope Francis’s memoir, Hope: The Autobiography, was the first memoir written by a living pope while in office and offers unusually personal reflections on faith, poverty, migration, women, LGBTQ+ people and Church divisions. It reveals that Pope Benedict XVI gave Francis a box containing documents on abuse, corruption and other wrongdoing, and recounts how British intelligence helped prevent an attack during Francis’s 2021 Iraq visit. However, the memoir leaves major questions unanswered, including Francis’s handling of allegations involving Cardinal Theodore McCarrick, his relationship with the Jesuit order, the transformation he underwent while in Córdoba, and accusations that he failed to protect fellow Jesuits detained by Argentina’s military junta. The article also examines Francis’s unconventional papacy, his Argentine nationalism over the Falklands/Malvinas issue and his tensions with Donald Trump’s policies.
The Independent
Apr 2025
What will really decide who becomes the new Pope
The next pope will be chosen through pre-conclave lobbying, personal alliances and the demographic and ideological priorities of the 138 voting cardinals. Although Africa’s growing Catholic population could make an African pope attractive, leading candidates Robert Sarah and Peter Turkson have conservative positions that may conflict with some electors. Francis appointed most of the eligible voters, but precedent shows that papal preferences do not guarantee the outcome. Many cardinals may instead seek a less divisive, unifying figure, with Italian candidates Matteo Zuppi and Pierbattista Pizzaballa, or Malta’s Mario Grech, seen as possible centrist choices. Ultimately, the conclave may again produce an unexpected winner.
The Independent
Apr 2025
Pope Francis: the revolutionary pontiff who changed the Catholic Church and the world
Pope Francis is remembered as a highly communicative and compassionate pontiff who brought greater visibility to ordinary Catholics, migrants, LGBTQ+ people and environmental concerns. He challenged the Church to respond to climate change, poverty, war and displacement while introducing some institutional reforms, including expanded roles for women and laypeople. His legacy is complicated by limited progress on the abuse scandal, continued opposition to women’s ordination, the controversy over restricting the old Latin Mass and his inability to bridge divisions between liberal and conservative Catholics.
The Independent
Jan 2025
The ‘nasty’ bishop is not alone – and Trump should brace for more episcopal fireworks
Donald Trump’s inauguration-era clash with Washington Bishop Mariann Edgar Budde reflects a broader conflict between the administration and Christian leaders over immigration, LGBTQ+ rights and the treatment of vulnerable people. Although Trump successfully courted evangelical and Catholic voters through opposition to abortion and appeals to Christian identity, churches and religious charities may resist his agenda, especially on deportations. The Episcopal Church has backed Budde, and the appointment of Cardinal Robert McElroy, a critic of Trump’s immigration plans, as Washington’s Catholic archbishop could bring further confrontation.
The Independent
Dec 2024
The Archbishop of York’s Christmas speech shows there’s been too much forgiveness in the Church
Stephen Cottrell’s Christmas sermon is criticized for using broad language about penitence and institutional failure without directly addressing allegations that he mishandled the case of suspended vicar David Tudor. Helen-Ann Hartley dismissed the sermon as “empty words,” reflecting growing demands for accountability after abuse scandals involving senior Church of England figures, including Justin Welby. The commentary argues that excessive forgiveness and repeated second chances for abusive clergy have historically protected institutions rather than victims, making meaningful action more important than general expressions of repentance.
The Independent
Dec 2024
As a ‘cuspy Waspi’ woman, I have another reason to be furious with Labour’s pensions betrayal
A woman born in 1959 explains how successive increases to the UK state pension age delayed her expected retirement income by six years, costing her an estimated £59,000. She argues that the government failed to properly notify women about the changes, a conclusion supported by the parliamentary ombudsman. Although Labour politicians, including Angela Rayner, Keir Starmer and Liz Kendall, previously backed the Waspi campaign, Kendall has announced that the government will not provide compensation, citing the country’s financial constraints. The writer says the issue is about broken political promises as well as money and concludes that the experience has damaged her trust in politicians.
The Independent
Nov 2024
Why we can’t (and shouldn’t) separate the God argument from assisted dying
The assisted-dying debate has become increasingly personal after Lord Falconer criticised Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood for opposing the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill on religious and sanctity-of-life grounds. Catherine Pepinster argues that Falconer and others are wrong to exclude religious reasoning from public ethics, maintaining that Christian and Muslim beliefs can contribute legitimate arguments about equality, inherent human dignity and the risks of state-sanctioned killing. She links religious opposition to assisted dying with historic Christian-led campaigns against slavery and capital punishment, concluding that belief in the value of every human life remains an important contribution to democratic debate on life-and-death issues.
The Independent
Nov 2024
Welby’s name is forever tarnished by abuse scandal – but forcing him to quit now would leave the Church in a mess
The Makin Report found that Christian barrister John Smyth abused at least 130 boys over four decades and criticized church authorities, including Justin Welby, for failing to show sufficient curiosity or make an effective police referral. Although Welby’s association with Smyth has badly damaged his reputation and prompted calls for his resignation, the commentary argues that he did not conspire to conceal the abuse and cannot be held responsible for every church body’s actions. It concludes that Welby should remain until his expected retirement within the next year, allowing a careful succession process and broader reflection on the future role of the Archbishop of Canterbury and the Church of England.
The Independent
Sep 2024
The Pope’s election intervention could be bad news for Catholics – and democracy
Pope Francis’s description of Donald Trump and Kamala Harris as competing “lesser evils” reflects the Catholic understanding of the sanctity of life, encompassing opposition to abortion, capital punishment and assisted dying as well as concern for migrants and climate change. Although papal interventions on issues such as communism and Nazism have historical precedent, the article argues that direct commentary on election choices is more dangerous. US Catholic voters form a significant but politically divided bloc, especially in battleground states such as Pennsylvania and Wisconsin. Francis’s attempt to criticize both candidates may still bring him close to telling Catholics how to vote, risking harm to the Pope, the Church and Catholics’ claims to exercise individual conscience.
The Independent
Sep 2024
Is Prince William living up to his father’s wish for him to champion the marginalised?
Prince William inherited from Charles III a public-service role focused on bringing marginalised people into the centre of national life. His work with The Passage, Centrepoint and the Homewards homelessness initiative is presented as ambitious and worthwhile, as are his criticism of racial injustice and the Earthshot Prize. However, the commentary argues that he remains too cautious and should use his platform to address human trafficking, ketamine addiction, dementia care and other issues affecting vulnerable people. After a difficult year in which both Charles and Catherine faced cancer, William is urged to become a stronger advocate for those without a voice.
The Independent
Oct 2023
I’m a Halloween Snob, but Even I’ve Fallen for Its Spooky Charms
A former Halloween skeptic explains why the holiday has grown on her after reflecting on its Catholic roots and its connection to All Saints’ Day, All Souls’ Day and the older Celtic festival of Samhain. A planned visit to New Orleans highlights Halloween’s mixture of gothic tourism, religious tradition and commercialism. The writer’s perspective also changes after hearing Jeremy Bowen describe grief at a Muslim funeral in the West Bank as part of the “politics of the dead”: Halloween’s artificial fears are possible because its participants are safe from the real violence and mourning experienced in war zones.
The Independent
Oct 2023
Is the Same-Sex-Supporting Pope the Tipping Point for the Future of the Catholic Church?
Pope Francis’s support for treating requests for same-sex blessings with pastoral charity signals a more compassionate direction for the Catholic Church ahead of its October Synod. His broader efforts to give local churches and lay Catholics greater influence, expand women’s roles, address clerical abuse, support migrants and prioritize climate action have intensified conflict with conservative Catholics. Women and gay Catholics are pressing for structural and doctrinal change, while the Synod’s expanded voting membership and parallel Spirit Unbounded gathering could make it a significant test of whether the Church can repair its divisions and remain relevant, particularly in Western Europe.
The Independent
Dec 2022
Friction over LGBTQ issues worsens in global Anglican church
The Anglican Communion is facing worsening conflict over same-sex marriage and LGBTQ clergy. Conservative leaders from Nigeria, Rwanda, Uganda and allied provinces object to Archbishop of Canterbury Justin Welby’s effort to maintain unity without imposing discipline, while LGBTQ-inclusive churches argue that their positions are grounded in serious theological reflection. The dispute intensified after the appointment of a dean in a same-sex civil partnership and ahead of a conservative-led meeting in Rwanda. The Church of England’s planned consideration of same-sex marriage proposals could further increase the risk of a formal split or expanded conservative influence.
The Independent
Dec 2022
Friction over LGBTQ issues worsens in global Anglican church
Divisions within the global Anglican Communion over same-sex marriage and LGBTQ clergy have intensified, particularly between conservative African and Asian bishops and more liberal provinces in the West and Southern Africa. Conservative leaders, organized largely through the Global South Fellowship of Anglican Churches and Global Anglican Future Conference, accuse Archbishop of Canterbury Justin Welby of failing to defend traditional teaching and are considering an impaired communion or formal separation. Tensions were heightened by the appointment of David Monteith, who is in a same-sex civil partnership, as dean of Canterbury Cathedral. The Church of England is preparing to consider proposals that could allow its priests to conduct same-sex weddings, while LGBTQ-inclusive leaders argue that their position reflects serious theological study. A possible vote by the Church of England’s General Synod and a forthcoming conservative gathering in Rwanda could further reshape the Communion.
The Independent
Jan 2016
The Name of God is Mercy: A Conversation with Andrea Tornielli by Pope Francis, translated by Oonagh Stransky — book review
The review describes Pope Francis's book, based on conversations with Vatican journalist Andrea Tornielli, as an accessible exploration of mercy as the central idea of Christianity. Francis argues that forgiveness, compassion and the possibility of redemption can counter modern despair and society's indifference toward poor people, homeless people and refugees. The reviewer notes the book's continuing emphasis on sin and anticipates that Francis's approach to mercy will be tested by forthcoming decisions on divorced and remarried Catholics and gay people. The book is recommended both as a guide to Christian thought and as an argument for practical compassion through the corporal works of mercy.
The Independent
Oct 2014
Why does this dreadful pink have to be the colour of breast cancer?
Breast cancer patient Catherine Pepinster objects to the pervasive use of bright pink ribbons, logos and clothing in breast cancer awareness campaigns, arguing that the color infantilizes women and reinforces outdated gender stereotypes. She supports efforts to fund research and raise awareness but wants patients treated as mature adults rather than symbolically reduced to femininity.
The Independent
Sep 2013
Book review: Band of Angels, by Kate Cooper
Kate Cooper's Band of Angels argues that women were central to the development of Christianity from its origins through the fifth century. Women spread the faith through family and social networks, helped Christianity gain acceptance within the Roman elite, and created alternative communities for widows and women who rejected marriage. The review highlights figures including Helena, Paula, Eustochium and Saint Jerome, as well as the influence of female scholarship and Marian devotion. Catherine Pepinster praises Cooper's detailed research and engaging narrative, while criticizing the book for presenting familiar feminist interpretations of the Gospels as though they were newly discovered and for being difficult to pitch to readers with differing levels of religious knowledge.
The Independent
Mar 2013
The God Argument, by A.C. Grayling
Catherine Pepinster reviews A.C. Grayling's The God Argument, which attacks traditional philosophical proofs for God's existence and promotes humanism. She finds Grayling's critique of religion useful in places but overly hostile, simplistic and lacking the wit evident in his personal manner. The humanist manifesto is likewise criticized for presenting an overly respectable and optimistic view of human nature while offering little comfort, redemption or hope to people who do not fit its ideal. The review argues that these limits help explain the continuing appeal of religious faith despite atheist rationalism.
The Independent
Feb 2013
Will the next Pope face south or north?
Benedict XVI’s resignation has unsettled Catholics because papal resignations are exceptionally rare and because his traditionalist leadership divided the Church. While he is praised for his intellect, writing and ability to communicate, he is criticized for failing to reform the Vatican amid abuse-cover-up and Vatileaks scandals. The next conclave may look beyond Europe to Africa or Latin America, but a change in geography may not bring a more progressive approach to sex and gender.
The Independent
Nov 2012
Christianophobia: A Faith Under Attack, by Rupert Shortt
Rupert Shortt’s book examines the persecution of Christians in Nigeria, the Middle East, Pakistan, India, China and elsewhere, linking it to Islamist fundamentalism, political upheaval, colonial legacies, ethnic tensions and local disputes. The review highlights the exodus of ancient Middle Eastern Christian communities, abuses against converts and blasphemy-law victims, and the murders of Shahbaz Bhatti and Salmaan Taseer in Pakistan. It also stresses that anti-Christian violence is not limited to Muslim extremists, citing Hindu nationalist violence in India and repression by China’s Communist authorities. The book is praised for documenting the scale of the problem and the responses of Christian institutions, but criticized for reading too much like a catalogue of abuses and relying heavily on advocacy organizations’ sources.
The Independent
Jun 2009
The Enemy of the Good, by Michael Arditti
Michael Arditti’s novel is reviewed as an ambitious family saga about faith, doubt and religious identity in contemporary Britain. It follows an Anglican bishop who has lost his faith, his Holocaust-survivor wife, their Christian painter son and other family members as they confront homosexuality, abortion, euthanasia, Orthodox Judaism, refugee experience, criminal accusations and personal crises. The review praises Arditti’s empathetic treatment of belief and his exposure of rigid religiosity’s absurdities, but argues that the many dramatic subplots sometimes strain credibility. It concludes that the novel’s central insight—that faith is both private and increasingly political in a multicultural society—is compelling.
The Independent
Mar 2009
Mother of God, by Miri Rubin
Catherine Pepinster reviews Miri Rubin’s cultural history of the Virgin Mary, praising its insights into the growth of Marian devotion, particularly in medieval Europe, and its use of women mystics and other perspectives to challenge the idea that the cult was solely a male construction. The book also examines Mary’s role in shaping Christian attitudes toward the body and her use in anti-Jewish polemic, while noting Islam’s more positive embrace of her. Pepinster criticizes Rubin for not fully explaining Mary’s spiritual accessibility to Christians and for giving limited attention to the Reformation, Protestantism, modern apparitions, Polish Marian devotion and John Paul II. Overall, the review finds the book illuminating despite these omissions.
The Independent
Jan 2009
Rowan's Rule
Rupert Shortt’s biography of Rowan Williams offers a detailed, partly cooperative account of the Archbishop of Canterbury’s character, theology and career. Williams is depicted as exceptionally intelligent, devout, generous and inclined to see every side of a dispute, qualities that became liabilities in an increasingly factional Church of England and Anglican Communion. The controversies surrounding Jeffrey John and Gene Robinson, particularly over homosexuality, exposed divisions over tolerance, tradition, biblical authority and church governance and brought the Communion close to schism. The review finds the book revealing and insightful but insufficiently authoritative in places, with its theological detail and internal church politics limiting its appeal to general readers.
The Independent
Nov 2008
A Lust for Window Sills, by Harry Mount
Harry Mount’s guide to British architecture is praised for its lively explanations of architectural styles, building techniques, churches, country houses and historical context. However, the review argues that the book presents a narrow, nostalgic and strongly Establishment view of England, concentrating on rural Britain and grand houses while neglecting railway architecture, the Arts and Crafts movement, and the architectural achievements of northern cities such as Liverpool, Manchester and Bradford. Its engaging style and useful introductory material are undermined by forced popular references and significant omissions.
The Independent
Jun 2008
The Phoenix: St Paul's Cathedral and the Men Who Made Modern London
Leo Hollis's book examines how the Great Fire of London in 1666 destroyed much of the city but also enabled its intellectual and architectural reinvention. Through the lives of John Evelyn, Nicholas Barbon, John Locke, Robert Hooke and Christopher Wren, it traces the emergence of empirical science, modern urban thought and a renewed Anglican identity. St Paul's Cathedral emerges as the book's central achievement and symbol, although the review notes that the narrative's movement between people and places can sometimes feel overwhelming.
The Independent
Jan 2008
Jesus Christ: The Gospels, Presented by Terry Eagleton
Catherine Pepinster reviews Terry Eagleton’s introduction to a Verso edition of the Gospels, examining the case for viewing Jesus as a revolutionary. She highlights Jesus’s rejection of wealth, respect for women and outcasts, and challenge to conventional family and social norms, while questioning Eagleton’s claims about ethical extravagance and non-resistance to evil. The review argues that Eagleton’s focus on the Gospels overlooks two millennia of Christian theology and practice, including both destructive idealism and traditions of justice and solidarity that influenced social and political movements.
The Independent
Sep 2006
Seminary Boy, by John Cornwell
John Cornwell’s memoir recounts how a deprived and troubled childhood in London led him toward the Catholic priesthood after a sexual assault and growing religious devotion. At Cotton College, he experienced an austere, highly regimented seminary environment marked by intense ritual, religious indoctrination, sexual anxiety and the threat of abuse, but also discovered books, beauty and intellectual opportunity. Although he abandoned the priesthood, the education helped launch careers in journalism, academia and writing, including trenchant criticism of the Catholic Church. The memoir ultimately explains both his continuing attraction to Catholicism and his critical perspective, culminating in a moving reconciliation with his father.
The Independent
Sep 2005
Opus Dei, by John L Allen
Catherine Pepinster reviews John L. Allen’s comprehensive account of Opus Dei, covering its origins, recruitment, finances, treatment of women, secrecy and mortification practices. She credits the organization’s members with serious religious commitment and notes its emphasis on lay spirituality, but questions the need for such a disciplined institution and rejects Allen’s sympathetic explanations of controversial practices. The review concludes that Opus Dei’s relatively small membership—around 85,000 worldwide and 500 in Britain—does not justify the level of public alarm surrounding it.
The Independent
Sep 2005
Cupcakes and Kalashnikovs: 100 Years of the Best Journalism by Women
Catherine Pepinster reviews Eleanor Mills’s anthology of journalism by women, praising exceptional reportage by Martha Gellhorn, Marie Colvin and Julie Flint alongside notable work by Erica Jong, Susan Sontag and others. She argues that the strongest pieces succeed because of their journalistic quality rather than their authors’ gender, while criticizing the collection for its narrow British-American scope, heavy representation of The Sunday Times, inclusion of Mills’s own work and conspicuous omissions such as Margaret Thatcher, the Queen and Polly Toynbee. Despite these flaws, she recommends the book as valuable reading for aspiring journalists.
The Independent
Jul 2005
Basil Hume: The Monk Cardinal
Anthony Howard’s biography portrays Basil Hume as a paradoxical figure: a humble Benedictine monk who became an exceptionally influential cardinal and public moral leader. Hume’s leadership at Ampleforth prepared him for Westminster, where he challenged establishment opinion by supporting the Guildford Four, Maguire Seven and Birmingham Six, whose convictions were ultimately quashed. He also managed difficult relations with the Church of England, the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament and conservative forces within the Catholic Church, including defending Lavinia Byrne against the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. Although Hume could be stern and lose his temper, he was widely loved and helped foster national spiritual and moral reflection despite the continuing decline in Catholic Mass attendance.
The Independent
Sep 2003
Ruth Ellis: A Woman Betrayed
Ruth Ellis, the last woman hanged in Britain, was convicted of murdering racing driver David Blakely in 1955 after a volatile and abusive relationship. The piece examines her traumatic upbringing, sexual and domestic abuse, class background, miscarriage and emotionally detached courtroom behaviour, arguing that these factors were inadequately considered at trial. During a later High Court appeal, Michael Mansfield argued that battered-woman syndrome warranted replacing the murder conviction with manslaughter, although domestic-violence experts questioned the usefulness of that label. Ellis's case continued to divide opinion between those who saw her as a murderer and those who viewed her as a victim of abuse and an unjust legal system.
The Independent
Sep 2003
Suzi Leather: Test-tubes and tantrums
Suzi Leather, chair of the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority, is portrayed as a forthright and pragmatic regulator navigating disputes over IVF safety, medical experimentation, clinic standards, embryo research and access to treatment. She advocates greater transparency, stronger enforcement powers and legislation that considers the welfare of embryos and prospective children, positions that have attracted controversy. Her background in bioethics, consumer advocacy and public service is presented as shaping an open, reform-minded leadership style, although she faces resistance from fertility specialists and concerns about the costs and limits of IVF.
The Independent
Aug 2003
Waugh Family Fury at 'Brideshead' Sequel
Businessman and writer Michael Johnston published Brideshead Regained, an unauthorized sequel to Evelyn Waugh's Brideshead Revisited, prompting legal threats from the Waugh estate. The book was allowed to appear only online and with a disclaimer stating that the estate did not authorize it. Johnston said he wrote the sequel as a tribute to Waugh and to resolve unanswered questions about Charles Ryder and the Flyte family, while the estate warned that it was neither approved nor collaborative and might infringe copyright. The dispute coincided with Waugh's centenary and broader controversies over adaptations of Waugh's work, including planned film and television projects that would significantly alter his original themes.
The Independent
Aug 2003
Our Janet leads by the mouth as celebrities take over the fringe
The Edinburgh Fringe is moving beyond stand-up comedy toward celebrity-led solo performances, monologues and raconteur shows. Janet Street-Porter’s daily rant All the Rage! is a major hit and may tour, while performers including Jo Brand, Paul Daniels, Nicholas Parsons, Rob Brydon, Susannah York and Daniel Kitson are attracting audiences with markedly different formats. Critics and performers suggest the trend reflects lower production costs, greater artistic control and the value of showcasing individual talent, with many solo shows already heading toward sellout runs.
The Independent
Jul 2003
Women to Be Offered Abortions at Home
The British Pregnancy Advisory Service proposed a pilot allowing up to 500 women who are no more than nine weeks pregnant to complete drug-induced abortions at home, arguing that this would make treatment quicker, easier and less invasive while increasing capacity. The plan would remove clinic attendance during the stage involving vaginal pessaries, with telephone medical support available around the clock. The Department of Health had not approved the pilot and said safety would determine whether home treatment could qualify under the Abortion Act. Anti-abortion organizations questioned whether women would have adequate support and warned about pain, incomplete abortions and other health risks.
The Independent
Feb 2003
Long Live Glorious Suburbia: Diverse, Accessible, Spacious, Sociable
Contemporary suburbs are defended against the longstanding cultural disdain associated with Virginia Woolf and the Bloomsbury Group. Although suburbs face crime, congestion and overcrowded transport, they continue to offer space, gardens, accessibility, diversity, sociability and family-friendly communities. The proposed Skyhouses—dense towers of up to 50 floors intended to address London's housing crisis—are presented as an inadequate substitute for suburban living, which remains attractive despite its unfashionable label.
The Independent
Dec 2002
On this Dirty Sunday, why not get out the Hoover and clean up your act
A humorous Christmas column uses the author’s cleaner’s unexpected return to Poland as a springboard for discussing household disorder, clutter and consumerism. The traditional pre-Christmas “Dirty Sunday” becomes a metaphor for moral self-examination, with criticism directed at celebrity relationship drama, Nancy Dell’Olio’s fashion, Madonna’s fur clothing, the Royal Family’s treatment of servants and the Catholic Church’s need for repentance and reform.
The Independent
Oct 2002
Lord Winston: He made dreams come true. Now he must act to stop IVF turning into a nightmare
Robert Winston, a pioneer of IVF and prominent science communicator, warns that assisted-conception techniques may carry greater risks than previously acknowledged, including birth defects and longer-term problems. He calls for authoritative research by the Medical Research Council and Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority, especially into frozen embryos and other techniques. The article also criticises private clinics that may exploit desperate patients, while highlighting multiple pregnancies and declining female fertility with age as major concerns.
The Independent
Oct 2002
Betjeman's 'Gentle Brent' and Other Urban Rivers Under Threat from DIY Plumbers
More than a million household DIY plumbing errors in Britain have allegedly connected toilets, baths, washing machines and dishwashers to rainwater drains, sending household waste into rivers instead of sewage systems. The Environment Agency says the resulting sewage fungus threatens fish and could reverse improvements in urban river quality, particularly in tributaries of the Thames such as the Brent, Crane and Mutton Brook. Councils can prosecute offenders and impose fines of up to £20,000, while the Plumbing Institute is calling for a registration scheme to prevent unqualified plumbers from causing environmental damage.
The Independent
Oct 2002
Champion of the “Forgotten Illness” Backs Independent on Sunday Campaign
SANE founder Marjorie Wallace supports The Independent on Sunday’s campaign for better mental-health treatment and warns that the proposed Mental Health Bill places excessive emphasis on compulsory detention and public safety. She describes shortages of psychiatrists, poor conditions in psychiatric wards, inadequate support for carers and the exclusion of families from treatment decisions. Readers’ testimonies reinforce concerns about stigma, missed diagnoses, insufficient intervention and the risk of treating mentally ill people primarily as threats rather than patients needing care.
The Independent
Sep 2002
William Trevor: The Quiet Chronicler of the Lost and the Damned
William Trevor is profiled as a private, understated Irish writer whose clear prose and finely drawn portrayals of loneliness, outsiders, poverty, regret and the persistence of the past have earned major literary recognition. Born into a Protestant family in County Cork and shaped by a nomadic childhood, Trevor deliberately lives in Devon because distance helps him write about Ireland. His short stories are widely admired, while some critics question whether his later fiction reflects modern Ireland. Despite his reluctance to engage with literary celebrity, he remains an influential and compassionate chronicler of marginalized lives.
The Independent
Sep 2002
Youth Hostels Up for Sale After Drop in Visitors
The Youth Hostels Association has put seven hostels up for sale and is considering selling two more after recording a £4m loss. Foot-and-mouth disease, the September 11 attacks and declining school group bookings caused occupancy to fall sharply, while rural communities fear losing associated tourist income. The properties, including historic buildings in Yorkshire, Derbyshire, Lincolnshire, Norfolk and Berkshire, have asking prices of up to £300,000 and would require planning permission for residential conversion. The YHA is also modernizing its facilities, targeting families and underrepresented groups, and opening hostels in seaside and urban locations as it adapts to changing visitor preferences.
The Independent
Aug 2002
Suzi Leather: 'We're not here simply in order to have babies'
Suzi Leather, chair of the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority, defends the use of embryos from IVF treatment in stem-cell research when couples give voluntary consent. She says donation must not be required for treatment and that IVF doctors should be separated from research requests. Leather supports embryo experimentation within the legal 14-day limit but sees personhood as a gradual process. She also warns against pressuring older women into infertility treatment, urges patients to compare clinics, and argues for equal access to IVF while rejecting the idea that having children is an absolute right.
The Independent
Aug 2002
Wayne Hemingway: Fashionista with designs on your home
Former Red or Dead designer Wayne Hemingway is applying his design principles to affordable housing. Working with his wife Gerardine and housebuilder Wimpey, he has designed the 700-home Staiths South Bank estate in Gateshead, with the first 158 homes receiving planning permission. The project emphasizes varied terrace-house designs, gardens, children’s play areas, reduced car dominance and flexible living spaces, with prices starting at £65,000. Hemingway hopes the development will challenge the conservative British housebuilding industry and lead to similar projects elsewhere.
The Independent
Jun 2002
F-word book gets the cold shoulder
British publishers have rejected Warwick Collins’s novel Fuckwoman, despite its publication and commercial success in Germany and France. Collins says the book, about a feminist vigilante who hunts rapists, is intended as a parody and a pro-feminist exploration of the sex war, while literary agent Christopher Sinclair-Stevenson attributes the rejection to multinational publishers’ fear of controversial writing and misunderstanding of the novel’s satire. The case is presented alongside Timothy Mo’s decision to self-publish after similar frustrations with major publishing houses.
The Independent
Mar 2002
'Spike' heralds new wave of skyscrapers
London could see as many as 20 new skyscrapers within a year, led by Renzo Piano's 1,016-foot London Bridge Tower. The Corporation of London argues that additional towers are essential to accommodate financial businesses and maintain the capital's status as Europe's leading financial centre. English Heritage opposes several proposals, warning that poorly located tall buildings could damage landscapes, protected views and residents' quality of life. Developers and planners defend the projects, arguing that modern towers can coexist with London's historic architecture.
The Independent
Mar 2002
Away from town, my boy breathes better
Michael Fielding developed severe asthma and multiple allergies as a young child while living in Beckenham between major roads. His mother, Jackie, observed that his breathing and general health improved whenever he stayed in East Grinstead, leading the family to move there. Away from heavy traffic and exhaust fumes, Michael has had fewer hospital emergencies and can play outdoors, although he still needs to avoid specific foods, cut grass and cold weather. His new school has introduced an asthma policy and staff are more attentive to his needs.
The Independent
Feb 2002
Naomi Campbell: 'I have every sympathy for her'
Tara Palmer-Tomkinson expresses strong sympathy for Naomi Campbell, saying that The Mirror’s pursuit of her while she attended Narcotics Anonymous meetings disrupted her own recovery from drug addiction. She argues that press intrusion can endanger people seeking treatment and fully supports Campbell’s stance against the tabloids.
The Independent
Feb 2002
Steve and Julie Pankhurst: Workers of the World, Reunite
Steve and Julie Pankhurst, creators of Friends Reunited, have launched Workplace Reunited, a service covering 400,000 employers that helps users reconnect with former colleagues. Friends Reunited grew rapidly after its 2000 launch, attracting millions of daily visits and nearly five million members through its school-based reunion listings. The couple attribute its success to widespread curiosity and nostalgia, while acknowledging fake entries, spam and allegations against teachers as major moderation challenges. They continue to run the business from their north London home but are beginning to explore commercial opportunities, including a television tie-in and a partnership with Rolo.
The Independent
Dec 2001
Cardinal Cormac Murphy O'Connor: A man of God who is going off Christmas
Cardinal Cormac Murphy O'Connor, Archbishop of Westminster and leader of Britain’s Roman Catholics, is preparing to celebrate Christmas Eve midnight Mass on BBC1 while seeking to establish his own public identity after Cardinal Basil Hume. He explains his earlier claim that Christianity was nearly vanquished, arguing that the response to the September 11 attacks revealed a continuing public hunger for spirituality. He condemns the commercialisation of Christmas, expresses opposition to violence and urges justice, peace, humanitarian aid and reconciliation rather than an unrestricted military response to terrorism. The cardinal also attacks the Government’s policy permitting experimental human cloning, while the profile notes the controversy over his earlier failure to act against an abusive priest.
The Independent
Nov 2001
Publishing's New Sensation: Dead Sea Scrolls
The complete publication of the Dead Sea Scrolls in 37 scholarly volumes marks the end of more than five decades of restricted access, academic disputes and controversy. Discovered near Qumran beginning in 1947, the scrolls provide original Hebrew sources that are roughly a thousand years older than previously available biblical manuscripts. Scholars say they demonstrate that biblical texts were edited and adapted over time, containing inconsistencies and multiple versions, while also challenging interpretations such as the Virgin birth of Christ. The findings are expected to prompt further debate among academics, Jews and Christians, and the Vatican is reported to be preparing corresponding revisions to parts of the Bible.
The Independent
Aug 2001
To Love, Honour — and Divorce?
Elisabeth Murdoch and Matthew Freud’s second marriage illustrates the continuing willingness of Britons to remarry despite high divorce rates. At the same time, demand for pre-nuptial agreements has risen sharply as couples seek to protect assets, although such contracts are not yet legally binding in the UK. The government has proposed giving them legal force subject to safeguards, while abandoning plans for no-fault divorce after pilot schemes appeared to strengthen couples’ decisions to separate.
The Independent
Jul 2001
Mormons pay £30m for prime British farmland
The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints had acquired about 15,000 acres of British agricultural land, spending at least £30 million over six years and becoming one of the country’s largest foreign landowners. Its latest purchase was the 2,000-acre Stubton Estate near Grantham for approximately £5 million. Through its farming company, Agreserves, the church said the land generated long-term income and food for humanitarian work, with £2.5 million from the farms reportedly supporting projects in Ethiopia and Kenya. Friends of the Earth criticized the church for not using organic farming methods, while the church argued that conventional farming was more productive and cost-effective for supplying food to needy countries.