Is Democracy Better Without Politicians?
Citizens’ assemblies are gaining traction as a way to give ordinary people a greater role in policymaking, with Belgium among the leading adopters. In Brussels, a randomly selected group of residents and MPs developed waste-management proposals, but participants’ confidence was shaken when elected representatives amended and overruled some recommendations. Examples from Ireland and France show both the potential for assemblies to influence consequential decisions and the risk of disappointment when institutions dilute or ignore their work. Advocates argue that assemblies can build civic connection and trust even when recommendations are not adopted, but their legitimacy depends on honest expectations, meaningful institutional follow-up and visible influence.

BerichtsstilAusgewogen
Reported feature combining firsthand observations and attributed views; its analysis is balanced but raises critical questions about the limits of citizens’ assemblies.