MB
Melissa Benn
Politics & Government · United Kingdom
Covers
Politics & Government
Education
Social Issues & Demographics
Health & Wellness
Arts & Culture
History
Seen in
Published work
The Guardian
Jun 2021
Ethel Rosenberg by Anne Sebba – a notorious Cold War tragedy
The biography of Ethel Rosenberg is explored as a deeply human story set against Cold War paranoia, highlighting her troubled upbringing, political awakening, and the injustices of the trial that led to her execution. Anne Sebba's portrait emphasizes Rosenberg's resilience, tragic circumstances, and the political hysteria that drove her prosecution, contrasting her courage with the actions of officials and family members who contributed to her downfall.
The Guardian
Apr 2021
Phone line helps headteachers cope with Covid burden
Headteachers across the UK have faced severe stress during the pandemic as they manage safety concerns, shifting government guidance and increased expectations from staff and parents. Former school leaders established Headrest, a confidential helpline offering rapid support and mentoring. Calls reflect widespread burnout, with many headteachers considering leaving their roles and future leadership pipelines at risk. Additional support from charities and limited government-funded counselling exists, but inconsistent provision and pressure from some local authorities and academy trusts worsen the strain. The helpline has helped some heads cope, though many still feel overwhelmed and disillusioned with the demands of the job.
The Guardian
Feb 2021
UK ministers accused of 'settling scores' by axing union adult learning fund
Workers and unions warn that the government’s plan to close the union learning fund will undermine adult education and hinder economic recovery. Employers, councils and politicians from multiple parties back efforts to save the programme, which has helped hundreds of thousands of adults improve skills and advance careers. Critics argue the cut is politically motivated, while evidence shows strong economic returns and widespread employer support. Concerns focus on disadvantaged workers losing access to flexible training opportunities, with fears that dismantling the system will have long-term negative consequences for both employees and businesses.
The Guardian
Dec 2020
Mass Covid testing at the drop of a hat is the latest bad idea for England's schools
Government plans requiring schools to implement mass Covid testing in early January are criticised as chaotic, poorly planned and imposed without consultation. School leaders warn the scheme is unworkable without shifting most pupils to remote learning and involving national or local health teams in supervising testing. The article argues that the plan reflects a decade of top‑down, understaffed and underfunded education policy, exacerbated during the pandemic by legal threats to councils and failure to collaborate with teachers. Rebuilding trust and listening to educators is presented as essential to prevent further disruption to schools and communities.
The Guardian
Aug 2020
Let's use this exams debacle to transform England's schools
Severe flaws in England’s exam grading system during the pandemic exposed entrenched educational inequalities and the limitations of high-stakes testing. Public backlash against the grading algorithm highlighted longstanding issues with GCSEs and A‑levels, including inaccuracy, inflexibility and disproportionate harm to disadvantaged pupils. Reform advocates, including figures across the political spectrum, are calling for replacement of GCSEs with more flexible forms of assessment. The piece argues for shifting control of educational reform from politicians to teachers, adopting broader and more meaningful evaluation methods, and redefining the purpose of schooling to support fairer and more effective learning.
The Guardian
Aug 2020
'Drill and kill' for England's state schools while private sector goes progressive
Private schools in England are increasingly adopting progressive, skills-based and interdisciplinary teaching approaches while state schools remain largely bound to traditional methods promoted by government policy. Educators highlight growing employer demand for teamwork, creativity and character skills, contrasting with state-sector emphasis on rote learning and test preparation shaped by reforms under Michael Gove and continued by Gavin Williamson. Some state schools such as School 21 and XP School demonstrate successful innovative models, but limited resources and political pressure constrain wider adoption. Rising dissatisfaction with memorisation-heavy teaching, combined with pandemic pressures, is prompting renewed calls for more collaborative and future-oriented education across the state sector.
The Guardian
Aug 2020
England's exam results fiasco has exposed its flawed education system
Government plans to standardise exam grades through an algorithm are condemned for deepening long‑standing inequalities in England’s education system. Teachers and school leaders warn that moderating results based on historical school performance unfairly harms disadvantaged students and undermines professional judgement. The crisis revives broader debates about punitive accountability measures, Ofsted’s role, the narrow exam-oriented curriculum and the marginalisation of lower‑achieving pupils. While the government remains resistant to reform, school leaders are increasingly vocal about the need for alternative approaches, creating a political opening for new educational policy discussions.
The Guardian
Jul 2020
'Only a zealot would oppose': should the UK nationalise struggling private schools?
Struggling private schools are increasingly seeking conversion to state status amid financial pressures intensified by the pandemic. Examples such as Queen Elizabeth’s Grammar School and Liverpool College illustrate perceived benefits, including stronger enrolment and improved performance under the state system. Advocates argue for clearer government processes to support conversions, while critics warn that integration may reinforce inequalities if converter schools continue enrolling disproportionately fewer disadvantaged students. The debate highlights tensions between preserving educational quality, supporting failing private institutions, and ensuring equitable access to state-funded education.
The Guardian
Apr 2020
'The gap will be bigger than ever': grammar school exams still going ahead
Grammar school entrance exams are set to proceed despite widespread school closures, raising concerns that the Covid-19 lockdown will deepen existing inequalities. Many disadvantaged children lack online access, resources, or suitable study environments, while pupils in independent schools continue to receive extensive remote teaching. Educators, charities, and parents warn that the 11-plus test cannot be fair under these conditions, yet selective areas face limited alternatives, with assessment-based replacements and cancellation both seen as unworkable. Local authorities and test providers are exploring adjustments or postponement, but uncertainty remains over how to address the inequities intensified by the pandemic.
The Guardian
Mar 2020
Councillor's 'oven-ready' scheme to force private schools to pay their bit
A councillor in Taunton proposes that local private schools contribute a portion of their business rate relief to support strained public services, arguing that the schools’ resources contrast starkly with nearby community needs. The plan is repeatedly blocked by councillors, some citing concerns about school finances, despite examples of international fundraising events. Supporters view the proposal as a low‑cost way for private schools to demonstrate public benefit, while opponents argue councils should not dictate how charities use funds. The debate reflects wider national scrutiny of private school tax advantages and growing pressure for reform as funding gaps between state and private education remain pronounced.
The Guardian
Jan 2020
Schools should brace for five years of upheaval from a triumphant party with Gove at its heart
The government is expected to pursue major education reforms led by figures such as Michael Gove and Dominic Cummings, with a focus on expanding technical education, increasing free schools, and accelerating conversion to academies. Funding increases will fall short of reversing cuts, despite having been driven by public and union pressure. Traditionalist policies on discipline and curriculum are likely to grow, while issues such as teacher workload, accountability burdens, and student wellbeing remain unaddressed. The article warns that past backlash against Gove shows that pushing radical reforms without regard for educators may provoke significant resistance.
The Guardian
Oct 2019
How the people of Rochdale launched their own fightback against sexual abuse and poverty
Rochdale’s Citizens’ Curriculum redefines adult education by focusing on the social and personal circumstances of participants rather than formal courses, helping residents affected by poverty, homelessness and sexual abuse rebuild their lives. The programme’s multi‑agency approach provides practical support, fosters confidence and enables people to pursue employment and education. Its community‑led model yields significant social benefits and cost savings while empowering individuals to recover from trauma and achieve stability.
The Guardian
Sep 2019
The private school system is ‘morally rotten’. This could be the moment for its downfall
Two new UK groups, the Private School Policy Reform thinktank and Labour Against Private Schools, are pushing for major changes to the private education sector as inequality and elitism draw heightened criticism. Supported by prominent Labour figures, proposals range from removing tax advantages to fully integrating private schools into the state system. Advocates argue reform is overdue and necessary to dismantle entrenched social hierarchies, while some conservative educators contend that high-performing state schools lessen the need for change. The political climate suggests growing momentum for significant restructuring of the education system.
The Guardian
Dec 2018
How can people protest about a grammar school taking in more poor pupils?
A backlash from middle‑class parents over plans for Birmingham’s grammar schools to increase places for poorer children highlights tensions surrounding selective education. Concerns about diluted academic standards mask fears of reduced access for affluent families, despite grammar schools’ historically low intake of disadvantaged pupils. Government efforts to tie additional funding to admitting more poorer students have produced minimal reforms, while objections from parents expose underlying social snobbery and entitlement. The piece argues that grammar schools entrench a two‑tier system and that equitable, high‑quality comprehensive education is the only meaningful solution.
The Guardian
Aug 2018
The only way to end the class divide: the case for abolishing private schools
The text argues that the divide between private and state education entrenches social inequality and weakens national cohesion, drawing on Finland’s move to a unified comprehensive system as evidence for the benefits of integration. It examines historical Labour Party commitments, critiques political reluctance to challenge private schooling, and outlines how subsidies, charitable status, and disparities in resources advantage privately educated students. Various reform proposals are discussed, including removing tax privileges, contextual university admissions, and integrating private schools through quotas or phased systems. The piece concludes that ending selective and private education structures would reduce inequality and strengthen the public education system.
The Guardian
Aug 2018
English schools are broken. Only radical action will fix them
Academy schools are described as failing due to inadequate oversight, excessive executive pay and poor performance, compounded by funding shortages, teacher retention issues and rising student stress. Long‑term cross‑party policies are blamed for centralising control and promoting market‑driven reforms. The article calls for Labour’s proposed national education service to redirect wasted spending, reduce testing, phase out selection, reform admissions and restore public control. International models such as Finland and Canada are cited alongside proposals for stronger teacher training, broader curricula and supportive accountability. A major shift toward equitable, comprehensive education is urged as the basis for a modern system.
The Guardian
Jul 2018
Brexit, austerity, economic woe: it’s time to make private schools pay
Argues that austerity, Brexit-related instability and widening inequality make it urgent for the political left to pursue reforms that curb the advantages of private schools. Highlights growing criticism of the sector’s exclusivity, support for measures such as ending charitable status, taxing fees and expanding contextual university admissions, and urges a determined push toward a more equitable education system despite likely resistance.
The Guardian
Jun 2018
Suggesting grammar schools ‘teach’ secondaries is a cynical insult
The schools minister’s proposal for grammar schools to form multi‑academy trusts with non‑selective schools is criticized as illogical, patronising and a defensive attempt to protect a failing selective system. Evidence from a BBC documentary and OECD findings is used to highlight how selection entrenches inequality, disadvantages poorer pupils and burdens secondary moderns. Growing opposition within government and the education sector has forced ministers to attach conditions to grammar school expansion funding, but these measures are viewed as inadequate. Critics argue that the only meaningful reform is the complete phasing out of selective schools in favour of a unified state system.
The Guardian
Jan 2001
Child of a dream
Comprehensive schooling is described as a formative and socially enriching environment that fosters openness, equality and genuine social mixing. Concerns are raised about government policies that encourage parental choice and forms of hidden selection, which undermine the comprehensive ideal and fuel middle‑class anxiety. Examples from Scotland and Cheshire are cited to argue that comprehensive systems can deliver strong academic results. Despite challenges, many schools still maintain a healthy social mix and educational vibrancy, reflecting the inclusive spirit that originally defined comprehensive education.