Don't Let Antisemitism Rewrite Your Judaism
Rabbi Steven Goldstein argues that antisemitism can operate by allowing outsiders to define which forms of Judaism are acceptable, particularly by separating Jewish identity from Zionism and Israel. Drawing on Jewish history under Greek, Islamic, Christian, Ottoman and Soviet rule, he compares contemporary efforts to marginalize Zionist Jews with earlier attempts to control Jewish religious and national expression. He criticizes Zohran Mamdani and Abdul El-Sayed, rejects the use of fringe Jewish groups such as Jewish Voice for Peace as representatives of Jewish opinion, and cites American Jewish Committee polling showing broad American Jewish support for Israel. Goldstein urges Reform Jews to defend both civil rights and Zionism while insisting that Jewish identity must be defined within the Jewish community’s own religious and historical tradition.
Reporting styleOpinionated
Complete opinion: a strongly persuasive Rosh Hashanah sermon defending Zionism and arguing that outsiders should not redefine Jewish identity.
Political contextCentre-right
Strongly pro-Israel and anti-anti-Zionist, while also emphasizing civil rights and Reform Jewish pluralism.